In July this year, Sydney Water went live with its new $40 million payroll system, Dayforce, which serves as a cautionary tale. Since implementation, the Australian Services Union (“ASU”) has alleged that hundreds of Sydney Water employees have consistently not been paid in full and on time – with some reportedly owed thousands of dollars. The ASU claims that Sydney Water proceeded with the implementation of Dayforce despite warnings from the union that the system was not fit-for-purpose.
This has prompted the ASU to initiate multiple legal actions, including a Notification of a WHS Dispute filed in the Industrial Relations Commission of New South Wales (“Commission”) on 25 August 2026. In its notification, the ASU has alleged that the ongoing payroll system failures created significant psychological health and safety risks for employees, including financial hardship and uncertainty.
What went wrong with Sydney Water’s payroll system rollout?
According to the Commission’s published notice, the ASU reported a range of issues on behalf of its members arising from Sydney Water’s implementation of Dayforce. Some of the alleged deficiencies and difficulties included:
Significant and unexplained under and overpayments.
Paid meal breaks for shift workers not being recorded as hours worked.
Accrued leave balances not being accurately transferred from the previous payroll system. Accordingly, leave applications were rejected because the system failed to recognise accrued entitlements.
Incorrect employee information, including bank account details, tax file numbers, hours of work, shift patterns and rosters.
The payroll system was “locked up” for up to a week each pay cycle, which prevented employees from entering roster changes, standby and call-outs.
Supervisors and management introduced “work-arounds” to deal with system limitations, eg. the system prevented employees from entering time worked between midnight and 12:15am.
Dayforce restricted the number of allowance items that could be recorded for each shift. This became an issue when some on-call employees were called out up to 12 times, however, only two could be entered per night.
Employees were not made aware of the Dayforce phone application and were not trained in its use.
What are the consequences of payroll system failures for employers and employees?
The ASU identified that lower-paid employees, shift workers and those who perform call-outs, standby shifts and have RDO arrangements were the most affected.
The ASU have called for Sydney Water’s senior leadership to be stood down without pay, highlighting the impact on the relationship between Sydney Water and its employees. The ASU have also sought orders that Sydney Water maintain and re-commission its previous payroll system to full functionality until Sydney Water could demonstrate that Dayforce would not result in any further payroll failures (among other orders).
These proceedings are ongoing and the total costs and impact to Sydney Water remains to be seen.
How can employers prevent payroll compliance failures? The three pillars of payroll compliance.
Sydney Water’s experience highlights that implementing a new payroll system is not simply an IT project. It is a significant employment and payroll compliance exercise that requires careful planning, testing and verification before a system goes live.
A payroll system must have the functionality and capability to accurately accommodate the actual working arrangements and entitlements of an organisation’s workforce. Testing should therefore focus (in particular) on the more complex and unusual working arrangements to expose any functionality gaps.
Effective payroll compliance relies on three fundamental pillars:
Interpretation – Correctly identifying and interpreting all relevant terms and conditions under the applicable industrial instrument(s).
Configuration – Ensuring a payroll system is correctly configured to capture all relevant terms and conditions (having regard to the proper interpretation).
Calculation – Ensuring a payroll system accurately calculates and processes employee wages, leave accruals and other entitlements in accordance with the applicable industrial instrument(s).
A failure in any one of these three areas can result in non-compliance, regardless of how sophisticated the technology may be.
How can employers check whether their payroll system is compliant?
Even with a well-established payroll system, employers should not assume that employee entitlements are being calculated correctly.
Proactive payroll compliance testing can help identify errors before they become widespread underpayments, costly remediation exercises or employee disputes.
How we can help
Cowell Clarke’s RemCheck service helps organisations assess their payroll compliance by reviewing and testing pay rules to identify potential discrepancies between employee entitlements and payroll calculations.
Whether your organisation is preparing to implement a new payroll system, has recently completed a transition or wants greater confidence in its existing payroll arrangements, RemCheck can help identify potential compliance gaps and support a proactive approach to managing payroll risks. Contact our Employment & Workplace Relations Team who can also provide advice should you have any queries or concerns. Contact Cassie Burfoot, Director, Daniel Bartlett, Senior Associate, or Jemma Andretzke, Associate, for further information.